Contrary to the title of the song, Caring Is Creepy never mentions caring being creepy at all. It’s pretty difficult to get any message, or even lyrics, out of this song. It is damn good though.
The instrumentals behind the voice of singer James Mercer sound incredible, though they do dominate Mercer’s vocals a bit. The song is quite interesting throughout and is centered around the unique Indie-alternative sound it creates.
Overall, I would rate the song a 9/10. It may not be easy to understand and the instrumental may be most of the song, but it’s still rather good. I enjoy listening to it, especially before resting. It has almost an hypnotic sound that I think is worth a listen: